MY WORLD CAFÉ
https://riversmeetproductions.co.uk/publications/
MY WORLD MUSIC
My World Music
"Not everything that is faced can be changed, but nothing can be changed until it is faced" - James Baldwin
I was at the Gaza/Palestine rally in Whitehall yesterday (18 Jan 2024) which was to have concluded with a march to the BBC and I witnessed all that happened.
The police banned the rally from being held, as originally planned, outside the BBC because they said it would offend the kahal kodesh (congregation) at a neighbouring synagogue during their time of service. The pro-Palestine movement have never threatened synagogues and, in any case there would be more Jews on the march than several synagogue congregations. These photos show orthodox Jews at the rally, descendants of holocaust survivors and the Jewish Bloc.
When the march organisers said they would rally in Westminster, place the Jewish Bloc at the front of the march, and arrive at the BBC long after any religious service, the police then changed the reason for the ban.It would be a nuisance to traffic. All marches are a nuisance to traffic. Their reasoning was obvious. The state broadcaster and its propaganda needs to be shielded from the opponents of the genocide they support.
After the Whitehall rally ended the organisers announced that they and some ‘celebrities’ present would now walk to the BBC and, if prevented from doing so, would lay flowers in front of police lines. To my way of thinking that is positively Gandhian. Later in the day The Guardian reported that "More than 70 pro-Palestinian demonstrators were arrested in central London on Saturday on suspicion of breaching protest conditions after some allegedly broke through a police line as they marched from a rally in Whitehall."
No one 'broke through’ a police line. Two lines of police stood aside and even drove their vehicles away from blocking the road. I walked through the first line and exchanged smiles with the cop I walked past. They clearly wanted the marchers to proceed. After Trafalgar Square a third line of police and their vehicles did not move aside and Chris Nineham, chief steward, then attempted to effect the laying of flowers in front of the police by Juliet Stevenson, an 87-year old holocaust survivor and others. No attempt was made to continue on to the BBC. Chris was violently arrested, held in custody for 19 hours and charged under the Public Order Act for 'organising an illegal demonstration'. Terms of his bail mean he is not allowed to organise or take part in any demonstration. This is a threat to all our civil liberties.
The truth is that the police wanted the marchers to go through their first two lines so that they could represent them as an unruly rabble set upon breaking through their lines. They successfully fooled The Guardian, but none of us who were there.
Michael Rosen puts it well...
“Arresting demonstrators who are posing no threat to public order, and posing no threat to individuals or groups, is an expression of state power ...It's hard to gauge, but it seems as if the mainstream media are finding it hard to sustain the idea that what Israel has been doing in Gaza is legitimate. But in essence, the view that Israel's acts are legitimate, is the government view and is part of its alliance with the US. It's just possible that some people on high made calculations that arresting people will discourage some from attending demonstrations ... It looks as if the Met has boobed. We can see film of the police letting the leaders of the march through (thereby collaborating with them in 'breaking the law'!) ”.
Chris Nineham was held for19 hours, charged under the Public Order Act and then released on bail. More than 40 others are still in custody as I write this. Release them all without charge Meanwhile we must charge the police and their State masters with using the laying of flowers in front of the police to move this country uncomfortably nearer a police state.
While writing this I received an email from a friend of mine ....
“Nothing about this (the events as described above) on the News. When I walked up Whitehall after my meet with friends at Tate Modern - I wandered into Trafalgar Square. I was wearing my Palestine scarf and a policewoman told me if I didn’t move in 30 seconds I would be arrested. I asked why. She said the square was a ‘non designated area’ and started counting . I said this was nuts and went off to see Francis Bacon. Earlier I had a Palestininan flag on my bag - a doorman at the Tate said I had to remove it. Why said I? Because the Tate is neutral. FFS
‘It Was A Light in The Dark’ ’ (The Guardian, 3 Jan.2025) was published to mark The Guardian’s decision to make War Child one of its charity appeal partners for 2025. Sadly it does so by straying far from the truth.
When writing about War Child’s music projects in post-war Mostar (Bosnia Herzegovina) and the work of the Pavarotti Music Centre (PMC), The Guardian claims that the centre ‘still provides music lessons and therapy to children in the city.’ There is NO therapy carried out at the music centre and NO music lessons. The only two music activities in the building are the town’s music school which has nothing to do with the PMC and Mostar Rock School which rents space from PMC for their work. Indeed when rock school organise concerts in the building they have to pay PMC for that! I need to add that the Rock School is as near as you get to music activities which reflect the early ideals of the music centre (bringing everyone together with music).
I do not wish to criticise anyone at the PMC today - some of them remain my good friends - but they are in an insidious position, unable to work alongside the centre's founding ideals and are subject to political controls. That is a result of the removal of War Child support.
War Child itself withdrew their support for the Pavarotti Music Centre soon after The Guardian’s 2001 article which exposed wrongdoing in the charity, and was followed by Jon Snow’s Channel 4 interview with Rosie Boycott (then Chair of War Child trustees). I was subsequently sacked by War Child for being the ‘whistleblower’ and as a result I had to leave my job as first Director of the music centre.
The parlous state of the Pavarotti Music Centre soon followed as the centre not only lost War Child support, but that of the patrons, including Luciano Pavarotti, Tom Stoppard, David Bowie, Juliet Stevenson and Brian Eno, among others. War Child has refused any support for the music centre for over 20 years and Rob Williams, then War Child CEO (salary £118,000), asked me to refrain from media comments without making clear that that I have no connection to the charity.
In 2017 I wrote an article which The Guardian published about my experience of corruption in the charity which I had co-founded. A year later the newspaper published an article about Orhan (Oha) Maslo and his great work as Director of the Mostar Rock School.
In conclusion I think it wrong for War Chid to be favoured as a Guardian 'charity partner' on the misleading assumption that they are involved with music projects that have sadly long-since disappeared,
I would like very much not to have to engage in any of this. I am 80 years old and have been ill. But Mostar is part of my life, indeed part of my family. Those who live there, and continue to unite young people with music, deserve to be served by the truth. That truth is not in The Guardian's "It Was A Light in The Dark". The light is coming from another direction.
Everything I mention here is supported by Guardian articles. See the below Guardian links.
David Wilson
co-founder War Child
First Director Pavarotti Music Centre
Guardian articles
STARS QUIT CHARITY IN CORRUPTION SCANDAL
MY GUARDIAN ARTICLE ON WAR CHILD AND CORRUPTION
Imagine that you are only able to hear one song or composition performed or recorded before all music is removed from your life. Perhaps, like Beethoven, you can no longer hear music. Perhaps, like Crusoe, you have been isolated on a desert island. This is the last music you will ever hear. It will be the music that you will only be able to recall from memory.
Andreea Vas - ‘The Great Gig in the Sky’ by Pink Floyd
Whenever I listen to it, the instrumental parts, the (very few, but no less meaningful) words, but mostly the amazing Clare Torry solo, it seems to sum up the human condition, from birth to death and with all the dichotomies of life in between: hope and desperation, love and sorrow, conflict and resolution.
Claudio Menci - ‘Bella Ciao’
My middle name is Antonio Donato, after Antonio Gramsci. My father was on the Left and I had Partisan relatives. My uncle, Donato, was part of the Resistance in Florence and he was my godfather who taught me from a very young age to hate weapons, armies and wars and to stay away from religion. My grandfather played the trumpet and told me to love music and that the best weapons are musical instruments. Antonio Gramsci is part of me and my family.
Christian Marti-Menzel - Talk of the Town" by The Pretenders
So evocative that contains all my memories, maybe because the song, like our lives, is gentle and harsh at the same time.
Merilyn Moos - Johann Sebastian Bach's ‘Prelude and fugue in B major’.
I wasn't even five when I listened, enraptured, to my mother playing Bach as if her life depended on it, on our beautiful old German piano. I would have dissolved myself into the sound if I could have. I took the piano for granted. It was not till decades later that I started to wonder how it had ever been got out of Nazi Germany. It took me even more decades to realise that my mother was playing for the ghosts of those whom she had left behind and who were later murdered by the Nazis. Now I listen to the music against the noise of bombs and missiles falling on the Palestinians in Gaza: another genocide.
Luna Maslo - ‘This Woman’s Work’ sung by Kate Bush
I imagine myself being 70 and listening to this song. As the song is playing beautiful melodies, I would be looking back on my life and questioning if my life's canvas was painted with bold enough strokes. Many people are concerned about whether they are going to accomplish enough in terms of a career or if they are going to have the biggest house on the block. My concern is if I am going to be brave enough to actually embrace life's very pulse. This song is full of being and feeling.
Dorothy Byrne - ‘Feeling Good’, written by Anthony Newley and Leslie Bricusse, and sung by Nina Simone.
A song of ecstasy and empowerment. At first, the lyrics are an ode to personal happiness, speaking of the joy of a new day and the freedom of nature. But the music builds in power to a climax at the line ‘Freedom is mine’ and becomes an anthem for all those who have suffered oppression and are determined to grasp their rights.
Pay-Uun Hiu - ‘4.33’ by John Cage
The piece I would choose would be ‘4’33’ by John Cage. I hope l will never lose my ability to hear the sounds that surround me as music, because that's what this piece is all about. I hope I will still be able to enjoy the chirping and twittering of birds as melodies, to feel the healing power in the drumming sounds of the waves, to hear the sparkling rhythmical patterns in the water of a brook. To unravel the songs of the wind. And let all of it bring harmony into my heart and soul. Then I will live happily after, hearing music all the time.
Senad Šuta - ‘My Life’ by The Beatles
I grew up with The Beatles, Elvis Presley and many others, but my first memories are related to the The Beatles, the greatest band of all time, My mother is guilty because had their records and she loved to sing their songs with my father whistling beside her. Aged 5 or 6 years old in Bosnia Herzegovina I didn't have any idea what the song was about, but the melody was enchanting. After I studied English in primary school I figured out that the song is about; love of life and love of friends, family, and lovers both past and present. A song for all of us, for all time.
Anthea Norman-Taylor - Karl Jenkins ‘The Armed Man’ (a Mass for Peace)
it is not music for the head or limbs, but for the heart. It makes me think of my daughters: Darla, whose beautiful voice rang out in a choir in Edinburgh at the first performance of the piece I heard. And the sentiment of the piece is for Irial and her endless work towards peace and justice for Palestine. I also like it because it makes me want to sing along, which is pretty rare in classical music.
Edwin Maynard - ‘Sans Frontière’ by Congolese singer and dancer M’bilia Bel.
A love song that celebrates the African diaspora from which we all stem. M’bilia Bel’s voice modulates effortlessly between languages - Lingala, French, and a wordless humming that speaks directly to the heart, concluding in a long ummmmmmm that feels like a breath of the Earth dancing out its dream.
Andrew Williams - Cello Suite No. 1 by Benjamin Britten (Opus 72)
This work, written in 1964 for the charismatic cellist Mstislav Rostropovich beautifully illustrates Britten’s ability to integrate classical and contemporary principles to create a work that is grand, sublime, and truly enigmatic. The rich harmonies make it easy to forget that it is all played on a single instrument. For me, this piece illustrates the ways in which music can enter right into us and resonate with the strings of our soul.
Russell Mills - Edward Elgar’s ‘Sospiri, op 70 (1914’
It was a close call between Elgar’s Sospiri (1914), Arvo Part’s Solfeggio (1963), and Hildur Guðnadóttir’s Fólk fær andlit (2020). In the end I plumped for the Elgar.
Javier Fariñas - Dietrich Buxtehude ‘Herr, wenn ich Nur Dich Hab’
This is a song to bless the soul and the lives of the dearest friends. Only the most special people.
Alison Martin-Campbell - ‘The Lark Ascending’ by Vaughan Williams
when I heard this for the first time when I was 20 and I couldn't move, I couldn't hink and I couldn't breathe. To this day, despite its popularity, if I hear it on the wireless or see it being performed on the television, I have to stop whatever I am doing takes over my whole soul, my whole being. I always cry when I hear it as it as it reminds me of so many things that have passed: my late parents, the ex-boyfriend who first played it to me and how fleeting life is.
Innes Sibun - Aretha Franklin’s ‘Amazing Grace’
It reduces me to tears every time I hear it because she pours her heart and soul into the performance and it is sublime.
Sue Dowell - Jean Sibelius ‘Symphonyin D major, Op. 43’
first heard it at the Proms in my 20s and it’s been my favourite piece of classical music ever since. Sad in places, but always hopeful, the music sweeps you along as it builds and recedes by turn, To me it has always felt like a perfect soundtrack for life.
Michael Walling - Pat Nixon's Aria, ‘This is Prophetic’, from Nixon in China by John Adams.
A strange musical memory, because it's about looking forwards. It uses the evocative power of a solo voice in an orchestral echo chamber to reach deep into experience and envision a genuinely humane society, one based on humility and trust.
John Claassen - Ennio Morricone, main theme from ‘Cinema Paradiso’.
I have always found this music surprisingly moving and emotionally resonant. It sneaks up on you and by the last marvellous sequence of the film, it provides a primal fusion of music and cinematic art. If it had to be the last piece of music I could ever hear it would always stay with me as a welcome earworm.
Alastair Hatchett - Beethoven’s ‘9th Symphony’
I first heard this symphony as a teenager in the mid-1960s and was overwhelmed by the music and especially the stirring fourth movement. In that movement a huge choir sings Schiller's ‘Ode to Joy’ (An de Freude) , with the chorus "all men are brothers". When the Berlin wall came down in 1989 there was a performance of the Symphony in Berlin at Christmas conducted by Leonard Bernstein. The 'Ode to Joy' was sung as the 'Ode to Freedom', so the word Freude was replaced by Freiheit. For many of us around the world, that was a moment of real hope
.Kevin Jefferies - ‘Nice and sleazy’ by the Stranglers.
An incredibly dark and beautifully produced record that grabbed me and made me pick up a bass.It is politically way ahead of its time and still sounds very relevant today...and the bass inspires me still.
Ben Wilson - ‘Drop The Pilot’ - sung by Joan Armatrading
This reminds me of the first ever concert my dad, David Wilson, took me to at Wembley Arena in for my 10th birthday in1983.
Dorothy Hughes - 'California Dreamin' by The Mamas and the Papas.
I love the group's music, but the harmonising in this piece transports me.
Alaistair Fraser - ‘The Strangest Dream’ by American folk singer-songwriter Ed McCurdy.
A great anti-war song and I remember singing it unaccompanied in various places - once in a tiny Irish pub on the banks of the River Shannon in Ireland, and a few years later at the ColBar in Singapore. When I was teaching at a boys’ school in Bournemouth in the '70s, I often wrote bits of drama performed by the students for the school assemblies. One year my piece was to celebrate the anniversary of the United Nations. As the boys laid down their mock rifles and uniforms on the school stage they sang this song. “I dreamed the world had all agreed ‘to put an end to war’.
Cecily Bomberg - ‘Stardust’ sung by Nat King Cole and 'Strange Fruit' sung by Billie Holiday
May I have two songs? The first I would like to hear in my last days is ‘Stardust’ and the other is ‘Strange fruit’. The first in memory of finally coming to terms with a great loss in a peaceful setting in my early youth. The second, when I began to understand something of the real world outside and what fear and hatred can bring about if we don’t fight it every day of our lives.
.Victoria Brittain - ‘We Shall Overcome’ sung by Joan Baez
It was the song of the US civil rights movement and the anti-Vietnam war movement which inspired me to take my little son and go to Vietnam as a young journalist and thereafter has been with with me in opposition to US backed wars from Angola and El Salvador to Iraq and Palestine.
Carole Vincent - ‘Unconditional Love’ by Gentlemen Without Weapons
As a lover of nature and its creatures great and small, I have chosen this song. GWW took sounds from the natural world & mastered them into a wonderful song. They set up the "Earth Love Foundation" in 1989 to encourage musicians to support rainforest conservation. We all know how important that is, perhaps even more so now.
Dilshini Sandhu - Beethoven’s ‘Fur Elise’
‘Für Elise’ is important to me, because of its simplicity and complexity. The juxtaposed feelings, from minor to major, capture someone's sadness and playfulness that can often exist simultaneously. It resonates with me because music is what feelings sound like and we often have several emotions existing within us simultaneously.
Murray McCullough - Bob Dylan’s ‘Knocking on Heaven’s Door’
I was at a social event in Mostar in ‘95 and a local chap said this song, which everyone there was singing, was the unofficial Bosnian anthem. When I asked why he replied , “because we have all been to Hell and now we are knocking on heavens door’.
'Brian O’Reilly - ‘Workers Song' written by Ed Pickford and sung by the Scottish socialist folk singer Dick Gaughan from his LP 'A Handful Of Earth'
An anti-war song that says everything about the lunacy of capitalism and war.
Steve Day -‘ The Beatles ‘Tomorrow Never Knows’
This Beatles song is a drone, an endless vibration. It speaks to everything we can’t see, but still feel. It has fed my desire to make music ever since I was a teenager, and still does.
LiljanaRadulj - the Dalmatian folk song, ‘O Marijana’
This song reminds me of hanging out with friends on summer nights.
Clifford Thurlow - Bob Dylan’s ‘Masters of War’
In this song we learn that old men and rich men and politicians make war for young men and young women and good people to be sacrificed. The song's themes never go out of date.'
Nina Lobmer - Queen’s ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’
.All music in one song
Jan Woolf - Beethoven’s ‘Piano Sonata No. 21 in C, Op. 53 -"Waldstein" - 3. Rondo (Allegretto moderato)’, played by Alfred Brendel
Many layers here . I heard it at Dartington hall some years ago. Brendel was too elderly to play and he introduced the piece played by a much younger pianist - and I thought how sad that must have been for him. The piece was sublime and helped transform a depression - so I downloaded it by Brendel and played it over and over later during the night.
Gillian Howell - Mozart’s ‘Clarinet concerto, A-Major 622’
It is one of those pieces of music that offer an unbroken connection between the past and the present.
Joanna Harrison - Mozart’s ‘Piano Sonata in C Major’ K 545’
As we get older music means more and more so this piece makes me think of the nostalgia of childhood but at the same time is uplifting.
Liz Huhne - Mozart’s ‘Piano Concerto No. 21 in C major, K. 467’
I played this for my husband Peter whilst he was in bed shortly before he died. A guitarist visited regularly and played this for him as well as Fats Waller’s “Your Feet’s too Big” and Louis Armstrong’s “What a Wonderful World”.
Sebastian Balfour - Johann Sebastian Bach’s Cello Suite No 1
It evokes a powerful memory of my mother. She was once a professional singer and had harboured musical ambitions for her three children. She wanted my brother, sister and me to form a piano trio. My brother was encouraged to learn the violin, my sister the piano and me the cello. My brother soon abandoned the violin for the trumpet. His passion became New Orleans Jazz and he formed a band. My mother was acutely embarrassed. My sister could play the odd Chopin Mazurka on piano, but never developed beyond amateur level. My teacher was a professional cellist and one of Pablo Casals’ pupils. I remember struggled to learn the Bach Suite. My memory is a mixture of disappointment and pleasure at the complex beauty of this magnificent piece of music.